Saturday, August 14, 2010

How do we value Freedom? - Anguished Plea by an Indian to fellow Indians

Somehow blogging never excited me since long, but today I had an urge to express something and here I am writing my first blog post, a day before our 64th Independence Day. As I was coming back from office, there were discussions around what needs to be done on Independence day, etc which triggered my thought process. The debate that went in my mind after that is the seed for this post :) This however was written in emotion than with a prepared mind. So please ignore if there are any grammatical mistakes and errors.



I was just wondering how much do we value the Freedom, our Independence now that we are enjoying the 64th year of it. How much do we value our freedom - The freedom to express anything and everything when we dont give a chance for our subordinates or colleagues or for that matter our parents to speak anything against our will,
The freedom to enjoy our lives without any fear when thousand others are dying in the borders everyday fighting for keeping us free,


The freedom to lead our life selfishly not caring for our fellow humans but expect everyone to pacify our ego,
The freedom to comment upon everyone as irresponsible for everythingthat is happening around when most of us shun to take up responsibility for the same everything,
The freedom to comment upon changing everything in our country when we are the reason for its condition as we move to foreign countries and dont even pay tax here.



I had a question to ask all of us, yes including myself. Do we think this freedom is free of cost-The freedom that was earned by millions of Indians who sacrificed their lives for the future generations, the freedom that is retained by thousands of soldiers spending their lives in our borders giving their lives, the freedom that is ensured by millions of responsible citizens. Is it of no value for us? Don't we care a damn about it? If we really do care, what have we done to realize the value of it? This was what Lord McAulay said about India in 1835.



But today, Is India the same as in 1835? I dont think we are the same any longer. We believe we have progressed a lot since Independence. But is this progress? We as a nation are so obsessed with foreign things, foreign culture, foreign branded clothing, foreign technology, what not, everything foreign from the way we live to the way we love :) Why are we so obsessed with everything imported and why do we love going to the foreign countries to make a living causing the brain drain? Since the time of ours', our parents and their parent's childhood we have been hearing that India is a developing nation. But we, our children, their children want to live in a developed nation, if not move to a developed nation like the US, Singapore, UK etc. When will we make the dream of making India a developed nation come true? It has to start somewhere.


We, the youth of the nation, may not be 100% of the population of our country but we are the 100% future of our country. If we run away from our country for earning in dollars and making a higher living, who is going to change the future of our country. We say that our government is inefficient and a bunch of corrupted old fools are running it. We say our laws are too old, the whole system sucks, we say our streets aren't clean, there are no trees or greenery anywhere in the city, we say that the transport system is screwed up, we say that our country can never change, we appreciate being "Slumdogs" and love it when the poverty of our country is awarded the Oscar.


We shout, crib, taunt,jeer and just keep saying it, just keep wondering why nothing changes, why we are the way we are. Nothing changes by its own. We have to be the change we want to see. We love the rules, the laws of the foreign, the rules to keep their streets clean, the traffic rules and everything else in the foreign. But in our own country, we give a damn to rules, we violate our laws, throw clutter wherever we are done with it, we break the traffic rules, we never pay our bills correctly. We boast about the foreign countries that they arent corrupted and says our system is screwed and rotten with corruption. But we are the ones who violate rules, corrupt the officials for mending or relaxing or even forming new rules for our own convenience.

When it comes to burning social issues like dowry, killing girl child, crimes against women, communal rights, regional rights, child labour we make loud drawing room protestations and continue to do the reverse at home. Our excuse? 'It's the whole system which has to change, how will it matter if I alone forego my rights to a dowry.'

Blame it on the system for everything and anything. How does the system form? We are the ones who use our vote, who use our rights to form it. What does a system consist of for us? For us it consists of our neighbors, other people, other officials, other religions, other castes, other creeds, other communities and the government. It’s always the "other", definitely not us. For becoming a better country, everyone of us needs to be a better citizen. As Maddy says in Rang De Basanti, "Koi desh perfect nahii hothaa hai, usey perfect banaaanaa padtaa hai". But what do we do instead?



When it comes to us actually making a positive contribution or making a difference to the system, we lock ourselves along with our families into a cozy corner and run for dollars to countries far away. Like losers, we run to the US to praise their system and enjoy the dollar dreams. When there is recession and the American economy is down, we run to the Australia. When Australians ill-treat us and even kill some of us, we run to the UK. When UK is in bad shape, we run to elsewhere. As a last resort, we come back to our country when we are thrown out by every other nation.

We don’t even use our "VOTE" but we expect the system to get better, someone else to clean the system, make it the best place for us so that once we are thrown out by the foreign countries during recession, come back to our country and enjoy the freedom earned and being retained by someone else. We are so habituated to enjoying the freedom that we don’t know the value of it. Our conscience is mortgaged to money.

So what do we do? Every generation needs to earn its own freedom and earn it for their next generation. Next time, we meet a soldier, we should thank him and salute him because for our tomorrows, they sacrifice their todays. One lesson we have learned from our history is that we haven’t learned anything at all. It is better to be late than never. We can work for a better India. We are all involved in politics, the outcome of it, which means we are the ones who can change the outcome. We are the system and hence if we change ourselves first, the system will change.

This blog post is not intended to blame or hurt anyone’s feelings, it’s just the anguish, an agony which is the outcome of an average Indian’s introspection on India’s 64th Independence Day. If this induces some thought for a change, makes ourselves indulge in our country’s progress, instigates an ounce of retrospection, pricks one’s conscience - that is considered the greatest achievement of this post. Let’s do what India needs from us.

JAI HIND


26 comments:

Sai Prasad said...

Great to see you blogging bhaiyya ! :) And a thought provoking post to begin with.. ! :) You rock as ever..

Ajitha said...

Awesome Thots Sarath ! Feels so good to see ur blog ! :) Very Lucidly written makes the reader think again abt all tht u said ! Good Job ! :)

Shiva Sarath said...

Thanks a lot Sai and Ajitha...Its all because of frnds like u...You motivate me to do such things :)

Unknown said...

Nice one Sharath :)
Keep Blogging ...

Vennela said...

You are right sarat...but I strongly believe in "Be the change you want to see..." A good read on independence day...:)

Siva Karthik Kakaraparthi said...

Nice one but I don't agree completely with all your thoughts (as usual :P). Frankly, my thinking was exactly like you in my yesteryears but recently it changed a bit (I believe I stepped up but not sure yet).

Coming to your blog,
1) Foreign Countries issue: I might be biased becoz I am in US myself but this is what I felt before I traveled across the seas and after too.

Gandhiji and Nehru ji who played a pivotal role in our Independence are foreign educated. Is that bad?? Did the people in the then India detest them for being foreign educated? They did bring minute losses to the educational system but what is important in the end of the day is the gain they brought to the country. They were exposed to much graver situations. Gandhiji was motivated towards the freedom struggle because of one incident: when he was thrown out of the train coz he was black. If he was left alone or if he did not go to SA then we might know who Gandhi was....

Regarding research: There are many many facilities in developed countries like USA, UK, and Australia which India cannot dream of or afford (no offense meant to India) in the next few decades. So, in the larger picture a person might be deemed useful in this world if he is contributing to the field of Science rather than brooding that my country is poor and it cannot afford the infrastructure needed and coz I am patriotic, I wont leave the country.

Also, most of the Indians today are working for MNCs whose bases are in countries like USA. So, profits and revenues are finally reaching US and somehow these MNCs are able to outsource work and resources to countries with less cost of living and increase their revenues.
Example: For a same piece of work, a person in US (no consideration to nationality) earns about 3 times (randomly picked..cud be more or less) more than the one who is living in India. So, in that case if willing, the person in US can actually use atleast 1x of his paycheck for the upbringing of India. This is actually happening.

Todays world is all about how well you can market your stuff. The brain drain is actually marketing the Indian brains and hence receiving multitudes of projects to India which are proving to be useful to generate jobs.

There are many more which I want to share but its 1:30 AM now and I am tired. Finally, I respect your feelings and opinions but as always each coin has two sides and we cannot actually say which side would have been a better choice as its a web connecting infinite links. I MIGHT BE BIASED AND SUPPORTING BRAIN DRAIN HERE BUT THIS IS STRICTLY MY OPINION.

Siva Karthik Kakaraparthi said...

Frankly, I share your opinion Sarath but I want to open up a debate and make it more interesting so I almost ended up posting another blog as comments...Sorry for spamming.

Shiva Sarath said...

Thanks Geetha and Suresh anna :)
@Karthik : I am not here to debate bcoz I just expressed my thought process :) Everyone has their own opinions and I completely respect that

Shiva Sarath said...

I didnt talk abt being educated in foreign but staying there for more than 5-10yrs during the most active period of life (20-35) which really doesnt make a difference to India even if u come back later on :)
Arent u in the US after u finished ur education. Wont u be there for 5more yrs..Be Frank :)

Regarding we working for MNCs we at least pay tax here and contribute some time of ours when we dont work..

Regarding research, whatever research is being done by Indians in US may reach India but comes with a lot of cost too :)

Indians in US use just 1% of ur paycheck even if u r earning 3tiems but here we directly pay 1/3rd as taxes and even more if u r inclined towards charity...

We will take more of this discussion offline..

My intention is not to compare Indians in US and Indians in India :)

Its for every Indian no matter where they are that we are so totally lost in our career and life that we forget our country....It happens for Indians in India too :) Its just my thought process and more of an introspection of self and nt a comment or critic of anyone :)

Siva Karthik Kakaraparthi said...

Sure Sarath. No heart feelings. :D

Its just that you never know how products of a reaction would change when the reactants of a reaction are changed especially when there are a billion reactants to consider.

Unknown said...

God thoughts..I wonder when will politicians write or rather read blogs like this and follow it..I also being culprit of not voting, vow to use "VOTE" power next election.

Shiva Sarath said...

Thanks Mohit for deciding to use your "VOTE" power
and thanks for your comments

Avinash said...

Good start Sarath maams!

Veena said...

Hey....Wonderful post......Liked it....The best sentence is " we appreciate being "Slumdogs" and love it when the poverty of our country is awarded the Oscar.".....I 100% agree to this.....Why did we feel so happy about THIS OSCAR!!!! Good one :)...

Veena...

Shiva Sarath said...

Thanks Avi maama :)
Thank u Veena

Unknown said...

gud1! Appreciate ur time and thotfulness for making this..
Hope to see it in 'Indidan' language next time :P..Just kidding..

Gud job buddy!

Keerthi said...

hey nice one...:)..keep it up :)

Unknown said...

Hi.. its is so nyc to see ur blog...
Nyc points u hav made...I hav a doubt actually,, wat u meant by FREEDOM ???

in my view INDIANS can go anywhere and can do anythng V hav right Live anywhr accorndg to constitution right???

and one more thng U told that... ppl of INDIA run for dollars to countries far away. Like losers we run to the US to praise their system and enjoy the dollar dreams. .. I wnt agree with this stmt bcoz INDIANS r not gng Lyk loosers.. If INDIANS r loosers Y those countries appointng INDIANS at Higher positions?

actually it is our country is not providing any platform to the intellectuals so they r runng to market them selfs.. its not a wrng thing.

It is our INDIA hav the issue of caste race etc,, politics play an imp role here.. see example in case y reservations r provided to BC ST SC and all..? see simple thing If a person Of OC candidate got good rank lyk 4000 in competative exam it is the govermt givng preference to ST getng 10,000 rank y it is givng preference to a unworthy fello..?
Y there r only 100 seats of Cardiology Medicine all over INDIA? Bcoz all the worthy candidates r sorted out at the beginig.. it is creating a -ve Imacpt it is the Governmt has to b changed.
u told that no one of us is usng the right to VOTE..
actually in this case aslo the Caste plays an imp role... It has become a tradition that their caste ppl has to b given preference while electing also.. it cant b changed by anyone.. ppl r adopted to that kind of mentality,,

hmm.. anyways im jst givng my opinion nothg more im nt here to debate.. nyc of u.. atleast a person lyk u hav to be there to invoke the feling of nationality at present bcoz ppl are more particular abt their caste forgetng all of us belong to one NATION (INDIA) & one RACE (HUMAN)...

Shiva Sarath said...

Thanks Pallavi,Keith..
@Teju: y so senti :) Appreciate ur comments

Sarang Date said...

Interesting thoughts. Nice start SSVS. I am in the list of non-voters since I am fed up of seeing politicians who lose elections by a huge margin sit on the chair as a home minister for 4 years... what's the use of electing then when even the results cant prevent a corrupt or a criminal from occupying the post in the parliament or the government. :-|... I may sound negative and sarcastic, but thats what comes to my mind whenever I think of voting

sushma srinivas said...

its nice siva... makes to think & realise... good... keep blogging....

Kaundy said...

Zup, sir!!

It's great to see an award winning blog, rather than a commercial blog! :-)
Great way to start with!
Truly professional!!
Please go on adding topics for your fans!

Unknown said...

nice thoughts...
i liked it..
especially the sentence
"When there is recession and the American economy is down, we run to the Australia. When Australians ill-treat us and even kill some of us, we run to the UK. When UK is in bad shape, we run to elsewhere"

waiting for the next one..

Shiva Sarath said...

Thanks Sarang ...I think we should put our efforts regardless of the results be it whatever..We should never give up...I believe the same holds good to voting too :)

Thanks Sushma vadina :)

Thanks a lot Kaundy..love all ur support..hope this brings abt a change in at least some ppl who read it and follow it :)

Thanks Teja...

Vanaja Ganta said...

Nice thought process Sarath, Keep rocking ... "Be the change you want to see"

Unknown said...

Sarath great to see you blog on India's 64th Independence day. You always had a great sense of timing and this blog is one.
Your blog did make me to introspect and think how relevant is freedom independence and Azaadi for the current generation. Yes I agree that we should value Freedom and the sacrifice made by our Elder generations for us. But how does the current Generation X relates to freedom. The conditions have changed from the 18th and 19th Century and GenX should define a new meaning to Freedom. It should articulate what it wants.

I do not agree with you on the Brain Drain argument as we have many persons coming back and investing in India. To me Brain Drain was the best for India as we had some Young and Bright talent who could nor make it big due to reservations and lack of oppurtunities. Every individual has freedom of choice where he wants to Study and work. In a Globalised World, where boundaries are getting blurred and Every nation dependent on other, GenX should think differently and get out of the old thinking.
I am sure the current Century belongs to INDIA and We can make it to the TOP Finanially, Militarily and Spiritually.
How to get there? GenX should be positive and Smart..

Cheers Krishna Kishore

Search This Blog